Some news for those interested in open-source publishing and “Open Science”: Dave Bacon is announcing the debut of scirate.com, a sort of social-networking site for physics preprints:
The idea came from the observation that while the arxiv is a amazing tool, one of the problems was that the volume of papers was high and, to put it bluntly, the quality of these papers was not necessarily so great. So the question became, how do I do something to filter out the arxiv? Now, of course, everyone will want a slightly different filter. One person’s noise might be indeed another persons operatic masterpeice. But there should be a way to produce at least “some” kind of filter based on the quality of the work. And certainly computers aren’t smart enough to do this filtering (okay that’s a challenge to all you AI people out there!) And using citations is too slow. But there is a group of experts out there who can do pretty good filtering…
[…] [E]ach day postings from the arxiv (actually only from quant-ph right now, see below) are listed onto scirate.com. If you are registered, you can then look through the listing and vote (or “Scite” as I call it) for the preprints. Then, when you display, or anyone else displays the page, the listing will be sorted by vote. So, with enough user participation, the hope is that the signal will “float” to the top. A noise filter!
So far, this only applies to the quant-ph category of the arxiv, because that’s what Dave is familiar with. He hopes to extend it to other fields in the future, though, assuming this actually works in practice.
It’ll be interesting to see if this takes off– I like the idea, because looking at the raw arxiv feeds is like drinking from the proverbial firehouse. If you’re interested in quantum physics and experiments in scientific publishing, go register, and vote for some good papers, and let’s see if this can be made to work.